Modern Dental X-Rays: Do We Still Need Lead Aprons?

Dental X-rays have come a long way since their introduction some seven decades ago, with digital radiograph equipment now significantly advanced. According to the American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology (AAOMR), the external radiation scatter, previously a concern, from modern X-ray technology is minimal and poses little to no threat to patients. Consequently, the AAOMR recommends that routine use of lead aprons and thyroid shields during dental X-rays may no longer be necessary.

Scientific Perspective on Protective Gear

Aruna Ramesh, professor and associate dean at Tufts University School of Dental Medicine, emphasizes that scientific evidence supports the notion that lead aprons and thyroid collars offer no additional benefit in preventing radiation exposure. 

Buyer’s guide to digital dental x-rays

The AAOMR’s new recommendations, outlined in the Journal of the American Dental Association, challenge the traditional use of protective gear, asserting that these measures may even interfere with obtaining clear X-ray images, necessitating repeat exposures and potentially doubling the overall radiation dose.

State Regulations and Patient Comfort

Despite these recommendations, changes in dental practices may be slow to materialize. Most states currently mandate the use of protective gear during dental X-ray procedures. Until regulations are amended on a state-by-state basis, dental teams are likely to continue utilizing aprons and shields. 

Additionally, the psychological comfort that lead aprons provide to certain patients, particularly pregnant individuals and parents of pediatric patients, should be acknowledged. Dentists may need to focus on clear communication about the rationale behind any changes and the data supporting these decisions as regulations evolve.

How to choose a dental x-ray sensor

Impact Beyond Dentistry

Similar concerns and regulations exist in other medical facilities where X-rays are performed on various body parts. Anthony Blatnica, chair of the radiation safety committee at Tufts Medical Center, notes that external scatter is minimal in these scenarios, making external shielding less logical. However, variations in regulations mean that the use of protective gear may persist until a comprehensive update occurs.

The Comfort Factor

Hugo Campos, director of oral and maxillofacial radiology at TUSDM, highlights the psychological role of lead aprons for patients, offering a sense of protection. Despite the scientific assurance of the safety of modern radiograph techniques, the emotional comfort provided by the traditional lead apron may influence patient perceptions. Balancing scientific advancements with patient comfort remains a nuanced aspect of modern dental care.