Delay in Sentencing: Court Challenge Surfaces in Case of Oral Surgeon Allowing Prison Guard’s Dental Procedure

CANADA: Sentencing proceedings for Dr. Louis Bourget, the oral surgeon who pleaded guilty to assault for permitting a prison guard to conduct dental work on a sedated inmate, have encountered an unexpected delay. 

The case, unfolding in Gander Supreme Court, witnessed submissions temporarily halted as defence attorney Randy Piercey contested the victim impact statement presented by the inmate, Blair Harris.

“In 40 years, I’ve never objected to a victim impact [statement]. I have to object to this,” asserted Piercey without elaborating on the specific grounds for his challenge.

Alleged Dental Hygienist Impersonator Faces Criminal Charges

Unusual Challenge to Victim Impact Statement

Victim impact statements, typically undisputed, provide a platform for crime victims to express the physical, emotional, or economic repercussions of an incident. In an unusual turn of events, Piercey’s objection to Harris’s statement has introduced a rare courtroom challenge. The written submission is yet to be disclosed in court, prompting Crown attorney Tina Walsh to engage with Harris in an attempt to resolve the matter.

As per the agreed statement of facts, revealed prior to the victim impact statement submission, unsettling details of the assault came to light. The incident occurred in October 2020 when correctional officers Ron McDonald and Roy Goodyear, accompanying inmate Blair Harris to Gander Family Dental Clinic, took an unexpected interest in the dental procedure conducted by Bourget.

Alleged Impersonation Scandal Rocks Dental Community in B.C.

“I got caught up in a teaching moment,” admitted Bourget, who regretted the decision after the extraction of four teeth, with McDonald performing the procedure while Goodyear recorded it.

The departure from standard procedure, where officers leave the room post-sedation, raised concerns. The dental assistant and nurse on staff expressed shock at Bourget’s decision, as disclosed in the court statement.

Future Court Proceedings

With Dr. Louis Bourget’s matter now scheduled to return to court on March 5, the sentencing submissions for Ron McDonald, who also pleaded guilty to assault, have been deferred until June. Meanwhile, charges against Roy Goodyear have been dropped. 

The unfolding legal proceedings bring to light a case that not only involves a disturbing breach of protocol but also a rare challenge to a victim impact statement in the Canadian legal landscape.