NHS Dentistry in Scotland Facing Recruitment Crisis

Shortage of Young Dentists Opting for NHS Work

UK: The dental sector in Scotland is grappling with a severe shortage of young practitioners willing to work in the National Health Service (NHS), leading to a recruitment crisis. According to David McColl, chair of the Scottish Dental Practice Committee at the British Dental Association, the appeal of cosmetic dentistry and the perceived stress of working in NHS clinics has lured many new recruits away from the public sector.

Younger Generation Seeking Better Work-Life Balance

McColl, who has been an NHS dentist for 37 years, stated, “Younger people have a different idea about how they want to work – they want a better work-life balance. They don’t want to come into an environment with a payment model where they’re going to be on this treadmill all the time. All that does is lead to stress and burnout. None of them really want to work a five-day week – they want to work on a part-time basis.”

Bupa to Close 85 Dental Practices Across UK Due to Staff Shortage

McColl also pointed out that social media has played a role in promoting the appeal of cosmetic dentistry among younger professionals. “That’s the ‘sexy side’ of dentistry, if you like – aesthetics. You only need to look at social media to see stuff about implants. That’s the world we live in now, and you can understand younger people wanting to go into that – it’s going to be a bit more rewarding than run of the mill,” he said.

Declining Number of NHS Dentists

The recruitment crisis has led to a significant decline in the number of high-street NHS dentists in Scotland. Figures show that the number of NHS dentists fell by 8%, from 3,038 in March 2020 to 2,791 in September 2022.

In an effort to alleviate the pressure on dentists, major changes were implemented to the NHS appointments system last year. These changes included an end to routine six-month check-ups in favor of a risk-based approach, where those with less healthy teeth would be seen on a more regular basis. Additionally, NHS charges for dental procedures, such as fillings, were increased after dentists complained that the previous fees were too low to cover their costs.

Dental staffing shortage leads to rise in part-time workers

Opposition Criticism

The Scottish Conservative health spokesman, Dr. Sandesh Gulhane, criticized the Scottish National Party (SNP) government, stating, “The responsibility for Scotland’s NHS dentistry being ‘the worst it’s ever been’ lies squarely with the SNP. Their funding decisions, abandonment of training and dire workforce planning have left patients without treatment or forced to go private.”

Gulhane added, “Their decision to create a tax gap with the rest of the UK is now – as they were warned – having a disastrous effect on recruitment, making it even harder to recover from their mismanagement, and leaving patients without essential health provision. Scotland is being let down by continual SNP failures.”

The recruitment crisis in NHS dentistry in Scotland highlights the challenges faced by the healthcare system in attracting and retaining young professionals, as well as the broader issues surrounding workforce planning and funding decisions made by the Scottish government.

Dental staff shortage and the Great Resignation